The Orange County Register today published Sheriff Sandra Hutchens' rebuttal to their editorial last week criticizing the Department for jail reform and the recently released Jail Audit.
This was her rebuttal:
Your editorial “Jail report: Spend more, reform nothing” provided a disservice to your readers and the community by misstating facts and giving the impression that the Orange County Sheriff’s Department used a jail audit to delay reform urged by the Orange County grand jury.
Reforms following the tragic murder of inmate John Chamberlain in October 2006 began even before the grand jury started looking into his death. That reform continues and has never been put on hold.
The jail audit was a top to bottom review of the county’s jail facilities and practices and policies of jail staff and administration.
The grand jury investigation brought to light some unprofessional practices that cannot be defended. None of the command staff responsible for those practices remain with the Sheriff’s Department. Jail commanders have been rotated and supervision within the jails has improved. There are more sergeants on the floor, we have computerized oversight of supervisor’s logs and enhanced video surveillance of both inmates and staff. Vulnerable inmates like John Chamberlain are now housed in a protected unit.
All of that was begun before the jail audit commenced and the effort continues on a daily basis.
My command staff and I have spent untold hours inspecting the jails and reviewing jail policies. We found a lot of problems but also a lot good practices worth keeping.
A 20-year study of in custody deaths in the seven Southern California counties showed that Orange County had the lowest death rate. Justice Department officials who inspected our facilities after Chamberlain’s death concluded, “the deputies we met were very professional, intelligent, and dedicated public servants who would be a credit to any organization.”
The consulting firm of Crout and Sida is one of the country’s foremost experts in corrections. Members of the firm spent over 1,000 hours examining every aspect of our jail system. They looked at the county jail system with a critical eye and made 115 recommendations for change.
Does that sound like they are recommending no reform?
Some of the recommendations provide savings but overall we have a need for more staff and improved facilities.
The price tag to implement the recommendations is something none of us want to hear in this time of cost cutting. Unfortunately it is true, we as a county need to spend money to fix our jails and run our system responsibly.
Your editorial calls for privatization of the jails to save money. While cities and the state are permitted to engage private firms to operate jails, a Sheriff under California law cannot. The Sheriff has a Constitutional requirement to operate the jails.
The use of non-sworn personnel to replace all deputies in the jail is another of your recommendations. Our jail deputies are mobilized in emergencies in Orange County. Many of the Deputies who helped evacuate homes in last month’s destructive wildfire work in the jails.
My comments to the board were minimized in your news reports. I do support and will initiate substantial civilianization of our jail staff but not at a level that would diminish our ability to respond to emergencies.
I am committed to jail reform and recognize the harsh truth presented by the Crout and Sida report.
Two years ago your paper took a hard look at the death of John Chamberlain. Perhaps it is time for your reporters to return to the story and see what changes have been undertaken since then. From the tone of your latest editorial, the change might surprise you.